Girls
- Abby Wise | 2021 |Quinnipiac University
- Hailey Thomas | 2020 | New York Tech
- Kathryn Mullin | 2019 | Salve Regina University
- Amanda Weber | 2019 | Molloy College
- Kristinamarie Kaszovitz | 2019 | Queens College
- Maddie Meehan | 2019 | Mt. Olive College
- Sarah Kinkel | 2019 | Springfield College
- Madyson Nuzzi | 2019 | Molloy College
- Brittany Sirota | 2019 | College of Mt. St. Vincent
- Lauryn O'Keefe | 2018 | Farmingdale State College
- Jamie Carucci | 2018 | Farmingdale State College
- Ally Petricca | 2018 | LIU Post
- Kelly Hughes | 2018 | LIU Post
- Caity Bianchi | 2018 | St. Leo University
- Amy Rzemieniewski | 2018 | Wagner College
Boys
- Jezayd Hall | 2021 | Uiversity of Albany
- Liam Daly | 2020 | Stony Brook University
- Otto Nicholson | 2020 | Williams College
- Nick Agresta | 2020 | Wingate University
- Justin Demonte | 2020 |
- Thomas Pellicci | 2020 | NYIT
- Matt Wang | 2020 | UPenn
- Andrew Arcuri | 2020 | Siena College
- Patrick Schuett | 2020 | McDaniel College
- Brandon Castellano | 2020 | NYIT
- Casey Romano | 2018 | Farmingdale State College
- Christopher Spahr | 2018 | St. Josephes College
- Rich LaCalandra | 2018 | Stony Brook University
- Craig Connor | 2018 | Florida Southern College
- Michael Hagenberger | 2018 | Lehigh University
- Robby Lopez | 2018 | Molloy College
- Nick Donnelly | 2018 | Belmont-Abey College
- Ashton Bradley | 2017 | University at Albany
- William Snelders | 2017 | LIU Post
- Jack Walsh | 2017 | Stony Brook University
- Kevin Gersbeck | 2017 | Lehigh University
- Jason Intermesoli | 2017 | Marist College
- Grifin Mcgrath | 2016 | University at Albany
- Matt Spahr | 2016 | University at Albany
